Readers and authors are missing the same piece of the publishing process: how do books actually get onto shelves?
Publishing has been a big scary box for a long time. Words go in, products come out. So let me answer the questions I get asked most.
1. “Can I get your books in a bookshop?”
Short answer, yes.
In theory, that’s all an author should need to worry about. In reality, authors showing up at bookshops and connecting with booksellers helps small presses like mine in a big way. So it’s worth knowing how that actually happens.
A bookseller orders copies through a wholesaler, who gives them a discount on the retail price, usually 40-50% RRP. The wholesaler goes to the distributor, who supplies the physical copies and delivers them to the shop. You may have heard recently about indie booksellers not receiving copies of a much-anticipated sequel to a romantasy book. I suspect that was an issue between the distributor and the wholesaler, maybe the delivery company too.
A good way to summarise it: being published, being orderable and being stocked are three different things. Anyone can publish a book fairly easily, and thanks to sites like Amazon it isn’t much harder to get one orderable. Being stocked is a whole other beast.
2. So, who are Gardners?
Gardners is the biggest wholesaler and distributor in the UK. Most bookshops, if not all, will have ordered from them at some point. Gardners gets every book’s details from Nielsen BookData, a free database where publishers and authors upload the content and metadata of their publications to get them onto shelves and into the industry. It isn’t strictly a requirement, but skipping it is a waste of money.
This is where the details get fuzzy for me. Gardners pulls the data from Nielsen and offers it to booksellers in categories, which seem to be based on how many copies a book has already sold. To count as “in stock”, a book has to be doing well already, probably through pre-orders. If it isn’t, as with most small presses and indie publishers, it’s categorised as “Firm Sale”: booksellers aren’t allowed to return the copies they don’t sell.
Why do they want to return books that don’t sell? Do you know how many books are published per year, worldwide? That’s why.
The Big Five and all their imprints can afford to accept returns because they can either resell the books elsewhere or destroy them. Yes, some books are destroyed if they don’t sell. I’m pretty sure a section of the M6 is built on top of Stephen King books that didn’t make it to readers’ shelves.
3. Available to order does not mean sitting on a shelf
Search for any of my books on the Waterstones website and you’ll find it, and you can order it. It’ll take forever to reach you, and I won’t see any of that money once Waterstones, the wholesaler, the distributor and the author have their share, but it’s possible. What you won’t be able to do, at least not yet, is walk into your local bookshop and see it on the shelf. There are simply too many books for the seller to choose from, and I don’t have the time or the petrol to visit every single one and convince them why mine deserve the chance.
That’s why authors are key to their own marketing. Authors can build local, personal connections with the bookshops around them, and booksellers are more likely to listen to someone who’s passionate about their book.
Technically, my books are available to order from Gardners, but booksellers don’t have the security of a return and don’t want to risk spending what little money they already have.
4. What this has looked like for us
I had a huge revelation while publishing A Year Without A Summer (AYWAS). Lesley had done, and continues to do, great work connecting with the people and communities around her, and there was some interest in hosting an event at a local Waterstones. But they couldn’t find the book in their database to order copies in.
So I sent a lot of emails to Gardners trying to work out how it all worked. Some people were more helpful than others, but the conclusion was this: I hadn’t sold enough copies. I did discover that IngramSpark is also a distributor, though. Great.
What it taught me is that an order, stock on hand and a reader actually buying a copy are three separate things, and the gaps between them are where small presses lose people. A book can be orderable and still never reach a reader.
It also left me thinking about keeping a small stock buffer of our own titles. If a shop or an event wants copies, having them to hand turns a maybe into a yes, instead of another round of emails. That’s worth exploring, but any extra stock would have to be agreed first. Printing and storing it costs money, and it isn’t something to fix by sending copies out unsolicited.
5. The small-press balancing act
Getting a book ready for shelves takes a lot: metadata, managing supply, handling orders, and keeping the author in the loop as much as possible. Getting it ready for commerce is another job entirely: trade discounts, printing costs, payment timings, and contracts and agreements that please the bookseller without leaving me too much out of pocket.
Have you noticed that book prices have been rising? Jealous of the publishers taking all that money? Don’t be. We barely see any of it. Everyone takes a cut, and everything left over is meant to cover production costs.
6. What authors and readers can do
- Order online and collect from the bookseller
- Order from the publisher
- Pre-order ahead of publication
- Talk about the book, all the time, with everyone you meet
7. The unglamorous work matters
So, can you get our books in a bookshop? Yes. Is it as simple as publishing them and waiting for the orders to roll in? Absolutely not.
There’s a lot going on between a finished book and a bookshop shelf, and I’m still learning how to navigate it. Gardners is part of that picture, but making a book available is not the same as convincing someone to stock it. That takes time, conversations, and people who are excited enough about a book to ask for it.
I don’t expect readers to become experts in wholesale discounts or distribution agreements. Frankly, I’d much rather you spent that time reading our books. But if there’s an indie title you’re excited about, ask your local bookshop whether they can order it. Take the ISBN, tell a friend, or pre-order a copy if you can. Buying directly from the publisher is always an option too.
Getting books into readers’ hands is the point of all this unglamorous work. And every time someone asks for one of ours by name, it’s a lovely reminder of why I bother.